Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jerome Simmons's avatar

This framework has aged well.

Recent earnings are starting to put numbers behind it. Salesforce reported 3.2B agentic work units last quarter, Workday says AI now drives more than 25% of new ACV, and ServiceNow has crossed $1B of AI ACV.

We’re increasingly moving from whether agents matter to which companies own the context, workflows and controls they need to operate.

Rohit Yadav's avatar

The three-pools framework is the clearest version of this argument I've read — most of the "labs vs. incumbents" takes flatten Intelligence, Platform, and Agent into one bucket and then argue past each other. Splitting them out is what makes the incumbent counter-strategy (own the system of record, then fight for the control point) actually legible instead of just defensive.

I'd push a little on the harness-stickiness argument though. You frame switching costs as coming mostly from cross-model prompt/context brittleness, which I don't disagree with, but the CIOs I talk to are just as stuck on a much less technical lock-in: nobody owns the platform decision internally yet. The agent sprawl happens because five different business units each bought a vertical agent tool before anyone in IT decided who controls the permissioned path from intent to action. So the platform imperative you describe on the lab side has a mirror problem on the buyer side — enterprises haven't decided who's allowed to be their control point either, and that indecision is arguably slowing platform consolidation more than harness brittleness is.

Your Microsoft/PC-platform analogy is the right one, but Windows had one company deciding the API. Right now enterprises have Salesforce, ServiceNow, and the frontier labs all pitching to be that layer simultaneously, and most CIOs I'm talking to haven't picked yet.

I wrote about this same platform-vs-agent-count problem from the buyer's chair here: https://theintelligencestack.substack.com/p/cdos-and-cios-are-asking-to-build

2 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?